Честит Великден
С вяра и доброта в сърцата, здрави и силни, да строим за хората! инж. Илиян Терзиев Председател на УС на КСБ
STATEMENT BY THE BULGARIAN CHAMBER OF CONSTRUCTION Regarding: § 80 of the Transitional and Final Provisions of the Draft Law amending and supplementing the Gambling Act, which proposes an amendment to Article 3, (1) of the Law on the Restriction of Cash Payments by introducing a total ban on…
Re: Section 80 of the Transitional and Final Provisions of the Draft Law amending and supplementing the Gambling Act, which proposes an amendment to Article 3, (1) of the Law on the Restriction of Cash Payments by introducing a complete ban on cash payments between construction companies, contractors and subcontractors under contracts for construction and installation works, the supply of building materials, machinery and equipment, as well as for related services.
The Bulgarian Chamber of Construction expresses its disagreement with the proposal contained in § 80 of the aforementioned draft bill and considers that it should be reviewed before being submitted to the National Assembly for consideration.
The proposed provision introduces a regulation that is unprecedented in its nature and scope, affecting solely the construction sector, without sufficient justification, analysis or evidence being provided for the necessity of such legislative intervention. More specifically:
The construction sector has consistently supported policies aimed at increasing the transparency of economic turnover, curbing undeclared economic activity and improving the collection of public receivables. We believe, however, that legislative measures in this regard must be based on a thorough impact assessment and a proven need for their introduction.
The supporting documents accompanying the draft bill do not contain convincing data to justify the need for a complete ban on cash payments in the construction sector, nor do they provide an analysis of the expected economic and administrative consequences of such a measure. Consequently, the proposal raises legitimate doubts as to its proportionality and effectiveness.
It is particularly worrying that the proposed ban applies exclusively to construction companies, contractors and subcontractors.
The explanatory memorandum to the draft bill contains no reasoning as to why the construction sector, in particular, has been singled out as the sole sector for which such a regime is to be introduced. No data has been presented to demonstrate that the construction sector poses a higher risk than other sectors of the economy or that there is a need for special and stricter treatment of this sector. The reasoning set out in the explanatory memorandum to the draft bill is far too general and markedly abstract – such considerations, precisely because of their vague and non-specific wording, could easily be applied to any economic activity, without, however, taking into account the fundamental characteristics of the free market as a whole and the provision of construction services in particular. Furthermore, the grounds create a presumption that the economic and financial transactions associated with the construction business are entirely lacking in the necessary transparency and traceability — an assumption that should, at the very least, be regarded as unproven.
Such an approach places the construction sector at a disadvantage compared with other economic operators and creates conditions for inequality between different economic sectors, without there being any objective and publicly justified grounds for doing so. Moreover, the regulation as formulated effectively discriminates against providers of construction services compared with other participants in market relations, and does so without any clear and objective criterion justifying the need for this legislative approach.
The explanatory memorandum to the draft bill sets out arguments that the proposed measure is intended to prevent ‘tax evasion’ and ‘reduction of tax liabilities’. It should be emphasised here that the effective generation of tax revenue depends, first and foremost, on the existence of an environment conducive to the unhindered and active realisation of market relations between economic operators. However, the introduction of the proposed restrictive measure would have precisely the opposite effect, namely an increase in unregulated payments aimed at overcoming the obstacles which hinder the smooth functioning of these market relationships and the associated financial flows.
Construction activity is characterised by multi-tiered contractual relationships, the involvement of numerous subcontractors, the delivery of materials and equipment to various locations and sites, as well as the need for operational efficiency in settling current payments.
A complete ban on cash payments would lead to:
At the same time, there is no evidence that such an extreme measure will lead to a real reduction in the informal economy or to greater transparency in the sector. Transparency in the construction process should be achieved through effective control, the digitisation of processes, the traceability of business transactions and the strengthening of administrative oversight, rather than through an absolute ban on a legally recognised method of payment. Unjustifiably, the ban covers payments for all services related to construction activities, including entirely routine works of a minor scale, without this being supported by market, economic, logical or any other arguments. 4. The proposed measure contravenes the principles of proportionality and reasonableness in state regulatory intervention
The prohibition provided for in § 80 constitutes a significant restriction on the freedom of economic initiative and the manner in which commercial relations are conducted in the construction sector. Such intervention must be duly justified, based on specific facts and supported by an impact assessment demonstrating the necessity of its introduction.
Pursuant to Article 19(1) and (2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Bulgaria, the law guarantees equal legal conditions for economic activity for all citizens and legal entities and creates conditions for free enterprise. In this sense, any restriction must be necessary, justified and proportionate to the objective pursued.
In this case, it has not been demonstrated that a complete ban on cash payments specifically in the construction sector is the sole or most appropriate means of achieving the stated objective of curbing the shadow economy.
________________________________________
Section 80 introduces a special restrictive regime applicable solely to the construction sector, with no analogous requirements for other sectors of the economy.
The lack of sound justification as to why a specific sector has been singled out and subjected to aparticularly onerous regulatory regime raises doubts as to whether the proposal complies with the principle of equal treatment and the prohibition of unjustified differential treatment of economic operators.
The proposer has not provided an analysis of whether similar risks of undeclared payments exist in other economic activities, nor has it explained why an exclusively sector-specific restriction is being proposed, rather than a general regime applicable equally to all participants in economic transactions.
Under Article 26 of the Law on Normative Acts, the principles of necessity, justification, predictability, transparency and consistency must be observed when drafting normative acts.
It is not clear from the explanatory memorandum:
We therefore consider that the proposal does not sufficiently meet the requirements for prior justification and the effectiveness of regulatory measures.
We must also pay particular attention to the legislative technique adopted to introduce the prohibition referred to in § 80 of the Transitional and Final Provisions of the draft bill. More specifically, the legal relationships concerning the performance of construction works have no connection with those regulated by the Gambling Act. There is a lack of the required systematic and functionally based approach necessary for the adequate regulatory framework of the legal relationships covered by this part of the draft Act. The manner in which the prohibition in question has been imposed is in itself indicative of its overall lack of merit.
In conclusion, the Bulgarian Construction Chamber (BCC) considers that § 80 should be removed entirely from the draft bill, as it introduces an unjustified sector-specific restriction which creates a significant administrative and financial burden on the construction industry, without its necessity, proportionality and effectiveness having been demonstrated. Should the state aim to further restrict cash payments, alternative mechanisms of general application should be considered, based on risk analysis, impact assessment and broad public consultation with representatives of the affected economic sectors.
С вяра и доброта в сърцата, здрави и силни, да строим за хората! инж. Илиян Терзиев Председател на УС на КСБ
Управляващият орган на Оперативна програма „Иновации и конкурентоспособност“ 2014-2020 (УО на ОПИК) предвижда да обяви процедура за подбор на проекти „Подкрепа на микро- и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“ Във връзка с възникнали въпроси от…
Процедура BG16RFOP002-2.073 „Подкрепа на микро и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“ ще бъде активирана в ИСУН на 14.05.2020 г. и от 10:00 ч. ще могат да се подават проектни предложения. Крайният срок за подаване на документи е 15.06.2020, 16:30…
От 14.05.2020 г. на уеб сайта на КСБ се предоставя възможност компаниите, вписани в Централния професионален регистър на строителя (ЦПРС), да обменят информация, свързана с участия в проекти по различни оперативни програми; да публикуват обяви относно търсене и предлагане на работна сила…