POSITION
OF THE BULGARIAN CHAMBER OF CONSTRUCTION
Engineering is just one of the forms of procurement provided for in the Public Procurement Act
Restricting this globally recognised practice would amount to serving the specific interests of a section of those involved in the investment process
In response to the position taken by the Chamber of Architects in Bulgaria (CAB) and the Union of Architects in Bulgaria (UAB) regarding the awarding of contracts for the construction of certain projects ‘on an engineering basis’, as stated at a press conference held on 21 November 2024 in Plovdiv, the Bulgarian Chamber of Builders expresses the following view:
At the press conference organised by the two professional bodies, a number of inaccurate, unfounded, subjective and biased suggestions were made, namely:
- “The outsourcing of engineering work on major public buildings does not lead to high-quality results” – this assertion is not based on any real evidence, nor on the practical application of the legislation governing the rules for the award and execution of ‘significant’ public contracts for the construction of buildings that are important to our society. In reality, the quality of construction of ‘significant’ public buildings depends to the greatest extent on the quality of the design work and the implementation of the investment project. The implementation of a project ‘on an engineering basis’ in no way hinders the creation of a good investment project, as the interests of the designer and the builder are aligned. Claims that the contractor places the designer in a subordinate position and pressures them into producing an unsightly and cheap product demonstrate bias and a lack of understanding of the principles of the investment process.
- “Awarding engineering contracts for major public buildings creates a risk of corrupt practices and the inefficient spending of public funds” – here, too, we are faced with a conclusion that is entirely unsubstantiated and not supported by any real evidence or practical examples. Engineering is by no means a significant prerequisite for corrupt practices in public procurement, nor is it a ‘technique’ used to artificially inflate the costs of design and construction. At the press conference itself, no examples were given of projects built using the engineering model that had acted as a ‘source’ of corruption, nor was there even a cursory explanation of how the application of this project implementation mechanism had made them more expensive or led to significant harm to the public interest. On the contrary, under the ‘engineering’ model, the design work is carried out by qualified professionals with full design authorisation (architects and engineers), rather than by the contractor. The ‘engineering’ form of contract award does not in itself in any way restrict either the rights or the responsibilities of the designers, nor does it allow for ‘independent’ participation in the tender and subsequent implementation of the investment project by the contractor. Builders cannot independently win engineering contracts, cannot independently carry them out, and cannot (nor do they wish to) do the work of the designers, thereby substituting their professional expertise!
- ‘Engineering turns the logic of the investment process on its head and directly selects a contractor to carry out the project, rather than holding an initial competition for an architectural design. This entails many risks associated with poor-quality execution, as well as conditions conducive to corruption and the misuse of public resources. Under the engineering approach, the local authority transfers its functions and responsibilities to a private individual (the contractor), who has an interest in producing a modest design with minimal resources in order to make a large profit’. We consider that the statements quoted, apart from being divorced from the realities of the investment process, are biased, offensive to the construction industry and aimed at creating a negative sentiment towards the contracting authorities and contractors in public engineering procurement. It is utterly irresponsible and manipulative to claim that builders have an interest in producing a ‘modest project’ with the aim of maximising profit. No contractor working on major public projects would wish to leave behind ugly, substandard buildings. Our impression is that, in practice, when carrying out a large number of projects, we encounter examples of poor-quality design, necessitating the revision of construction documents during the course of the works, which delays and increases the cost of project implementation. Unfortunately, it is mainly the builders who are required to pay penalties for the resulting delays.
- “Engineering must not be permitted in the construction of schools. In the modern understanding, a school is a space for learning, yet we continue to build them on the principle of barracks.” Even if there is a grain of truth in this statement, it is hardly the application of engineering principles that is to blame for the lack of modern aesthetics and functionality in some school buildings. It is laughable to claim that the client who opted for an engineering-led approach, or the builder who ‘subordinated the designer’s aesthetic vision to their desire for profit’, are to blame for the ‘barracks-like’ appearance of some schools. Clearly, an internal discussion is also needed within both professional bodies with a view to achieving contemporary standards in the work of designers and ensuring these are upheld on a permanent basis.
- ‘European practice recommends holding architectural competitions, as these lead to the best long-term results’. Once again, this claim is not supported by real-world examples from European countries, by official European Union documents, or by analyses and reports from European institutions.
In order to dispel the misconceptions and false suggestions cited so far, we shall briefly introduce you to the essence of engineering and its advantages.
The ‘Design and Build’ (engineering) method, practised worldwide, is a strategy for realising investment projects, which provides clients with a single point of contact throughout both phases of the process – the design and construction phases. In this way, a single contractor bears the responsibility and contractual risk for every aspect of the process – from pre-investment studies, calculations and the pre-construction phase through to architecture, coordination and execution of the construction works, and the post-construction phase.
A closer look at the engineering strategy reveals the following:
Unlike other construction methods, here the clients enter into a contract with just one design-build contractor. With the other two main methods used today – construction management and general contracting (known as design-tender-build) – clients contract with different individuals or organisations for architectural design and construction. As engineering integrates all stages of a project, the designers work in coordination with the members of the project team. Under other methods, the design phase is carried out separately, which often leads to unforeseen costs and delays during the construction process. The ‘Design and Build’ approach gives the project team an insider’s view of investment management and the opportunity to discuss various options for implementing the project. The end result is a robustly designed project, a reasonable budget and a feasible schedule. Unlike other design and build methods, here the five phases of project delivery overlap and all team members collaborate throughout the process to ensure the client’s objectives are met quickly and effectively.
What are the benefits of applying the engineering strategy:
- Faster implementation, as design and construction take place simultaneously and there is only one procurement phase instead of two. Engineering significantly reduces design and implementation timescales, particularly in the case of projects awarded with European funding, including those for the current programming period up to 2027. The time required to carry out several procedures under the Public Procurement Act (for the selection of a designer, including the prescribed time limits for appeals; approval of an investment project; followed by a procedure for selecting a contractor with appeal deadlines, etc.) makes it impossible to complete construction within the current programming period, and this jeopardises the implementation of EU-funded projects, as well as projects under the National Programme for Energy Efficiency (NPEE), for example – the energy efficiency projects for all local authorities for which no contracts have yet been signed.
- A smooth and hassle-free investment process for the contracting authority. The difficulties caused by poor coordination between numerous teams and the contracting authorities are eliminated. The responsibility, assumed entirely by a single contractor as proposed by the engineering firm, is clearly to the client’s advantage, sparing them the hassle of the ‘passing the buck’ between several parties involved in the investment process.
- Better communication and fewer problems. Adopting a team-oriented approach encourages high levels of communication and transparency – both of which are absolutely essential to the success of any project. A team-oriented approach also ensures the collaborative effort needed to assess project objectives and schedules, and to analyse opportunities as the project progresses. Engineering makes this possible. All team members are working towards the same goal, as everyone is working under the same contract. And clients liaise with a single point of contact authorised by the contractor. For this reason, engineering is well-suited to the most complex projects, simplifying them so that clients can achieve better quality, make fewer claims and receive a completed building without resorting to legal disputes. One should not overlook the fact that the execution of a vast number of public construction contracts, which are not carried out through engineering, is severely hampered by the poor quality of investment projects due to a lack of communication with the contractor. This necessitates the revision of projects during the course of construction pursuant to Article 154 of the Spatial Development Act, which significantly delays the implementation of projects and, in many cases, increases their cost. For this reason, we consider that, should the Public Procurement Act adopt an approach involving special provisions for contracts within the investment process, there should be regulations clarifying the designer’s liability for substandard designs that have caused harm to other participants in the process. A similar approach will also be proposed in future amendments to the Spatial Development Act and, in particular, to the Ordinance under Article 171(2) of the Spatial Development Act (on compulsory professional indemnity insurance for participants in the investment process), which currently provides for only nominal liability cover for designers.
- Cost savings. Owing to its efficiency, engineering often reduces construction costs for clients. In 1998, the Journal of Construction Engineering and Management published a detailed article demonstrating how much time and money engineering saves compared with other strategies. It was found that engineering-led projects are completed more quickly, are more cost-effective and involve fewer requests for changes during construction, which lead to unforeseen costs and delays. In other words, the engineering approach enables projects to be completed on time and within budget. This makes it possible to reduce the cost of a given project by nearly 9 per cent, rather than, as some would have us believe, constituting a waste of public resources.
In view of everything set out so far, we state that the claims made by the two professional organisations are based on false, manipulative and subjective assertions. The participants are proposing highly inappropriate solutions for ‘optimising’ the process of awarding and executing public contracts for design and construction works. The Chamber of Architects in Bulgaria (CAB) and the Union of Architects in Bulgaria (UAB) are unjustifiably seeking to restrict freedom of contract and deprive contracting authorities of complex projects of the most appropriate tools for their implementation. The results sought by the architectural profession could be achieved not through restrictive measures, but by regulating a fundamentally new mechanism for evaluating tenders, for carrying out construction in accordance with FIDIC rules, as well as by introducing a more effective system of control throughout the entire investment process. There is also a need for more detailed regulation of the responsibilities of those involved in the investment process, including designers and those carrying out design supervision.
In conclusion, the Bulgarian Chamber of Construction considers that engineering is merely one of the forms of procurement provided for in the Public Procurement Act. The Act itself neither obliges nor restricts any contracting authority from making an informed choice of procurement strategy for any given contract, in accordance with its own views, resources and time constraints. Restricting a globally recognised practice would amount to serving the specific interests of a section of those involved in the investment process. It is precisely such a restriction that would affect the quality, effectiveness and efficiency of the execution of a large number of projects.
The Executive Board of the Bulgarian Construction Chamber