Latest News

The Bulgarian Construction Chamber has lodged a complaint with the relevant authorities against the guidelines issued by the Operational Programme for the Environment, which render the indexation methodology meaningless

The Bulgarian Construction Chamber has lodged a complaint with the relevant authorities against the guidelines issued by the Operational Programme for the Environment, which render the indexation methodology meaningless

Ref. No. 00-225/6 October 2022 TO MR GULAB DONEV, PRIME MINISTER OF THE REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA, ARCH. IVAN SHISHKOV MINISTER OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND URBAN PLANNING MRS ROSITSA VELKOVA – ZHELEVA, MINISTER OF FINANCE DR ENG. ROSITSA KARAMFILOVA, MINISTER OF THE ENVIRONMENT AND WATER REGARDING: GUIDELINES ON…

Ref. No. 00-225/6 October 2022

TO

MR GULAB DONEV, PRIME MINISTER OF THE REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA

ARCH. IVAN SHISHKOV, MINISTER OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND URBAN PLANNING

MRS ROSITSA VELKOVA-ZHELEVA, MINISTER OF FINANCE

DR ROSITSA KARAMFILOVA, ENGINEER, MINISTER FOR THE ENVIRONMENT AND WATER

RE: GUIDELINES FROM THE MANAGING AUTHORITY OF THE OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME ‘ENVIRONMENT’ ON THE APPLICATION OF THE METHODOLOGY FOR ADJUSTING THE PRICE OF A PUBLIC PROCUREMENT CONTRACT AS A RESULT OF INFLATION, APPROVED BY COUNCIL OF MINISTERS DECREE No. 290 of 27 September 2022

DEAR PRIME MINISTER,
DEAR MINISTERS,

In fulfilment of its statutory obligations arising from Article 117a of the Public Procurement Act, the Council of Ministers adopted Decree No. 290 of 27 September 2022, approving the Methodology for adjusting the price of a public procurement contract as a result of inflation. The Decree was published in the State Gazette, Issue No. 78 of 30 September 2022, on which date it came into force. Pursuant to Article 1 of the adopted Methodology, this document regulates the procedure for adjusting the price of a public procurement contract and a framework agreement as a result of inflation, whereby there has been a significant increase in the prices of the main goods and materials constituting the value of the construction contract and the framework agreement for construction. Consequently, the Methodology constitutes an algorithm by which the parties to a contract, as described in Article 1, may arrive at the exact amount by which the initial contract price is to be adjusted.

The Methodology, unlike the Public Procurement Act, which forms its legal basis, introduces certain restrictions regarding construction works that are subject to indexation. This is set out in the transitional and final provisions. More specifically, the restrictions are as follows:

  1. Prices for works carried out, accepted after June 2021 under public procurement contracts and framework agreements for construction, are subject to adjustment /§ 4/. For this reason, the Council of Ministers excludes the possibility of works accepted before 30 June 2021 being subject to indexation, regardless of when their value was quoted. Even if these works were quoted after the starting date for the calculation of inflation, as set out in §.2 – 31 December 2020 – they cannot be subject to renegotiation between the parties to a given contract. It should be clarified here that the ‘acceptance’ of a particular activity should be understood as the completion of a specific procedure for accepting the work carried out by the contractor, as provided for in the contract itself, and the drawing up of certain documents certifying this. Should a contract not expressly provide for such a procedure, the provisions of the Spatial Development Act and the subordinate legislation governing its implementation shall apply accordingly. It is also important to note that the methodology requires the acceptance of a particular item of work, rather than its full or partial payment by the contracting authority. This provides grounds for concluding that indexation also applies to unpaid works that have been accepted after 30 June 2021;
  2. Neither the Public Procurement Act nor the Methodology imposes a restriction requiring that the performance of a contract must not have been completed for it to be subject to indexation. We consider that even ‘completed’ contracts may be subject to price adjustments, provided that the construction works under them were accepted after 30 June 2021. It is worth noting here that, in many cases, the performance of a construction contract is not limited to the drawing up of Form 15 or even the commissioning of the project. Even after the completed project has been commissioned, the contractor remains bound by a number of obligations until the expiry of the warranty periods agreed in the contract for the various types of construction works. In such cases, the contractor would also be entitled to request indexation of the contract price;
  3. In the Methodology, December 2020 is taken as the starting date for the existence of inflation /§2/. For this reason, the date for determining the value of the construction and installation works, which is the subject of an amendment to the calculation of the contract value and the framework agreement, is set as the date of the tender for participation in the public procurement procedure, but not earlier than 31 December 2020. Should a tender be submitted before 31 December 2020, the index for 31 December 2020 shall apply to it /see §3/.

The legislative basis for the adoption of the Methodology (Articles 116 and 117a of the Public Procurement Act) also contains important principles that should be borne in mind when applying the contract indexation mechanism, namely:

  1. The legislator, as evident from the wording of Article 117a(1), has stipulated that the application of the Methodology with regard to the indexation of contract prices falling within its scope is a mandatory obligation of the contracting authority. This means that if a contractor under a contract, which by virtue of the law and the Methodology itself is classified as eligible for indexation, requests a change to the price of that contract, their request binds the contracting authority to initiate the procedure for applying the Methodology without fail. A refusal to initiate the procedure would constitute an unlawful act on the part of the contracting authority;
  2. The legislator has not restricted the scope of indexation to a specific category of contracts depending on the type of contracting authority (municipality or the State) or the method of funding

(state budget, municipal budget, a specific operational programme, etc.), nor to a precisely defined subject matter of the contract or framework agreement for construction;

  1. The Public Procurement Act itself has set a so-called ‘indexation cap’, which is 50 per cent of the value of the main contract or framework agreement. This ceiling cannot be altered by a Council of Ministers decree, instructions from a specific administrative body, or further restricted at the discretion of the contracting authority. This means that all well-founded and lawful requests for indexation should be granted up to the statutory limit of 50 per cent. Any excuses regarding a lack of the necessary funds for indexation would be in breach of the provisions of the Public Procurement Act.
  2. The Public Procurement Act does not require contractors to submit any supporting evidence to contracting authorities in order for their claim to be upheld. It is sufficient to make a reasoned request for the application of the methodology, based on the existence of a specific legal basis.

In view of the legal conclusions set out above, the Bulgarian Chamber of Construction expresses its bewilderment and dissatisfaction with a number of provisions in the Guidelines of the Managing Authority (MA) of the ‘Environment’ Operational Programme /OPOS/ regarding the application of the methodology for adjusting the price of a public procurement contract as a result of inflation, approved by Council of Ministers Decree No. 290 of 27 September 2022, which demonstrate a completely perverse and one-sided interpretation of the principles of the Public Procurement Act and the Methodology. We shall take the liberty of quoting only the most striking assertions made by the MA, which to a large extent render the application of the indexation mechanism meaningless:

  1. In a context of limited financial resources and in accordance with the principle of sound financial management, the MA of the OP Environment has the option to provide grant funding in an amount sufficient to ensure an increase in the value of contracts concluded with selected construction contractors of up to 15 per cent (fifteen per cent) of their value. The increase in the grant is exclusive of VAT where the expenditure is ineligible, or inclusive of VAT where VAT is eligible.
  2. The update to the value of the grant will be carried out by concluding a Supplementary Agreement to the Grant Agreement and will be a one-off adjustment, with the maximum applicable percentage being 15 per cent at the level of an individual contract with a contractor.
  3. The Managing Authority of the OP Environment will consider requests to update the value of the grant in the order in which they are received. The MA will apply the following criteria when approving a request to amend the budget under the ADBFP, whilst reserving the right to exercise its discretion in accordance with the circumstances:
  • Financial resources are available under the procedure, priority axis and programme;
  • The contract, in accordance with the Public Procurement Act, with the selected contractor for construction and installation works or engineering services has not been completed.
  • It is a mandatory condition that the construction and installation works have not been completed and/or, if they have been completed, that they have not been accepted or paid for by the Contracting Authority under the relevant contract. Contracts under which all construction and installation works have been completed, accepted and paid for by the Contracting Authority are not subject to indexation.
  • No final request for payment under the ADBFP has been submitted to the OPOS Managing Authority, and the project activities have not been completed.

DEAR PRIME MINISTER, DEAR MINISTERS,

We wish to express our outrage at the approach taken by the OP Environment Managing Authority, which has, from the very outset, undermined the process of implementing the Methodology, which was eagerly awaited by the entire construction sector. We hope that, through swift and appropriate action, you will help to overcome the bureaucratic and unlawful approach demonstrated by the OP Environment Managing Authority. Such a mindset and course of action will lead to the failure of hundreds of projects across all operational programmes, as well as to significant adverse consequences for the entire construction sector.

Driven by the desire for a swift and successful launch of the indexation process, we propose that meetings be held with you as soon as possible, at which we can discuss the above-mentioned issues and, through joint efforts, overcome the tendency towards a purely symbolic and formal application of the provisions of Council of Ministers Decree No. 290 of 2022.

Yours faithfully,

ILIYAN TERZIEV – CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE BCC



Latest News

Related articles

See all →
KSB

Грантова схема „Подкрепа на микро и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“

Управляващият орган на Оперативна програма „Иновации и конкурентоспособност“ 2014-2020 (УО на ОПИК) предвижда да обяви процедура за подбор на проекти „Подкрепа на микро- и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“ Във връзка с възникнали въпроси от…

KSB

Процедурa BG16RFOP002-2.073 „Подкрепа на микро и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“ стартира на 14.05.2020 г. от 10:00 ч.

Процедура BG16RFOP002-2.073 „Подкрепа на микро и малки предприятия за преодоляване на икономическите последствия от пандемията COVID-19“ ще бъде активирана в ИСУН на 14.05.2020 г. и от 10:00 ч. ще могат да се подават проектни предложения. Крайният срок за подаване на документи е 15.06.2020, 16:30…

KSB

НА УЕБ САЙТА НА КСБ СЕ ОТКРИВА ФОРУМ ЗА СТРОИТЕЛНИТЕ КОМПАНИИ

От 14.05.2020 г. на уеб сайта на КСБ се предоставя възможност компаниите, вписани в Централния професионален регистър на строителя (ЦПРС), да обменят информация, свързана с участия в проекти по различни оперативни програми; да публикуват обяви относно търсене и предлагане на работна сила…

Professional ties